benefit They're Real Push-up Gel Eyeliner Black

Not-so-smudge-proof

HOW are people saying this is smudge proof?! It is anything but!!! It ends up all over my eyelids by midday, and I don't exactly work in a hot environment. I work in an office and it just doesn't last. So disappointed.

2014-09-06 by Lacon

This eyeliner is perfect for a slick dramatic look. My only recommendation is please buy the 'they are real' eye makeup remover. I had difficulties removing this with my regular eye makeup remover

2014-09-01 by Tashy

Freaking amazing! Best eyeliner I've ever used!

2014-08-16 by Therese

Fantastic product

best product I had used. It lasts long and easy to use

2014-08-13 by daisy4869

benefit liner

absolutely amazing product ,i love it,stays put all day

2014-07-30 by aliona

Clumpy Disappointment

This liner is such a disappointment, it doesn't come out gel like, it comes out in hard clumps. Even if you work as fast as possible with it once you've wound it up it just doesn't apply properly. Once you persevere with it, and finally do manage a line, it then flakes over the day leaving little black dots under your eyes! Terrible.

2014-07-29 by Zu

Maybe it's just me...

But I find this pen really hard to use. There is barely any formula at the end of the pen which leaves me twisting the bottom so more comes out, then there is too much so it comes off in blobs on the eyes. The gel is really thick and does not apply smoothly, rather collects in little lumps at the lash line. It does not appear to be long lasting either, as my wings rubbed off easily using just my finger. Perhaps I am just doing it wrong but I will definitely go back to using felt tip liners.

2014-07-29 by Ella

It's ok

I find it not as smooth on the eye. I like the concept of gel liner in pen form. It's very black and Matt. I just find it not as easy to do flicks. I usually use felt tip liners. I like the product but not enough to re purchase it

2014-07-28 by Mo

It is not as easy as commercial tells you. It needs a lot of practice to make a nice line. The biggest plus is that it is super long wearing: you can wear it all night, or all day or even near the pool and not to worry that it will make you black circles under the eye. Gives nice deep black mat finish. But as I said before practice.. practice ...practice

2014-07-24 by Svetlana

benefit push up liner

Bought this but didnt expect amazing results. My eyelids are oily and have tried all types of liquid and gel liners over the years-all of which transfer 'everywhere'. Working for a french cosmetic house, i know my stuff but was truly shocked at how effortless this is to apply, the staying power and the ability to achieve matching flicks on both eyes (not one eye pointing out and the other pointing up!) Admittedly this is a luxury purchase as a little over priced but if you really do struggle to apply your eyeliner this is an absolute godsend 9/10

2014-07-19 by marks